|
Open Letter To The honorable Dick Cheney
By Nolan K. Anderson
10/29/05 "ICH
" -- -- Mr. Cheney, now that the United States has
almost completely destroyed its own reputation, value system and
integrity in the eyes of the world, you are proposing to influence
enough lawmakers into re-making even a theoretical positive image of
the United States into that of a third rate, third world
junta-controlled fascist state, complete with all the inherent
trappings of torture, terror and tyranny that makes these regimes
feared and loathed around the world. (Quite an objective for any
tyrant). Even with the stigmas of Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo, Bagram,
Diego Garcia and Falluja fresh in the minds of the world, you are
attempting to legitimize the gutting of the Geneva Convention and
the U.N. Convention Against Torture by placing the barbaric tool of
torture in the hands of a few “CIA sadists” to justify pursuing an
unjustified war started and pursued by you and your president.
The 38 percent of the American population, which presently supports
you and your leader’s actions, will keep dwindling as the suffering
caused by body bags and missing body parts reaches closer and closer
to their living rooms. But, by the time they realize that your need
for the use of torture will never stop at the shores of the United
States, it will be as late for THEM as for any conscript purchased
from an Afghan war lord and designated for “CIA squeezing”.
By a recent vote of 90 to 9 in the United States Senate an amendment
to the Defense Appropriations Bill was written and sponsored by a
former Viet Nam POW who can vouch for the value of torture as a tool
of intelligence gathering. So far as we Americans know, Senator
McCain never yielded to the pressures of torture to reveal
information that would be of value to the enemy during his 5 years
as a POW. Do you think Senator McCain is the only person in the
world who will not give information valuable to the enemy even under
torture and without hope of release from his tormentors? Oh, yes, I
know you have a wealth of information to the contrary in the dark
recesses of the hidden world of the CIA torture archives and the
archives of extraordinary rendition torture chambers around the
world. General Pinochet's DINA files could convince one that torture
can be used to “break” anyone. And, I have no argument with that
thesis. However, there is a difference between “breaking” a person
mentally/physically and gaining useful information.
There is a price for everything. What is the price for being
considered a “third rate, third world junta-controlled fascist
state, complete with all the inherent trappings of torture, terror
and tyranny”? So long as you can’t be defeated, there would appear
to be no real price to be paid because no one can hold you to
account. But, we had to cede the mantle of invincibility when we “so
heroically advanced to the rear” – just as the French had done - in
Viet Nam. Since then, we have contented ourselves with attacking
such “giants” as Grenada, Panama and now Iraq. Grenada and Panama
went as planned; but, Iraq is turning into a PR nightmare to spin as
a victory. As the Romans learned, “there never was a horse that
couldn’t be rode nor a cowboy that couldn’t be throw’d”. The image
of our “invincibility” has not convinced the “insurgents” not to
fight us even considering our Abu Ghraib, and Guantanamo and Bagram.
They see us for what we are – weak and unprincipled – as defined by
our politicians and our policies.
So, as you can gather, I am against torturing prisoners for any
reason – for the simple reason that I have no interest in being
considered as barbaric as those we label as terrorists. If we can’t
defeat them in a “fair” war that follows the rules of civilized
nations that thousands of American heroes have died to define, then
what is the value of “victory”? Oh, I know. Each war is different.
We have to adapt our strategies to those of our enemies who use
torture as a deterrent, to intimidate and as a means of gathering
intelligence. Yes, I know, we have to fight them on their level.
Well, we a fighting them on their level and we aren’t winning!
Nolan K. Anderson is a retired engineer and a veteran of Korea who
was once a “conservative” until he found there was nothing left to
conserve. He may be reached at
nkanders@tds.net
Translate
this page
(In accordance with Title 17
U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed without profit to
those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the
included information for research and educational purposes.
Information Clearing House has no affiliation whatsoever with the
originator of this article nor is Information Clearing House
endorsed or sponsored by the originator.) |
