We Do Torture
By Robert S. Becker
" -- -- “We do not torture,” broadcasts the president,
adding the next memorable signpost for his troubled tenure. Four
simple words but they represent the most telling admission about his
insular administration, I propose, since the just slightly premature
“Mission Accomplished” boast. That claim now seems as antiquated as
American prestige and as distant as “bin Laden: dead or alive.”
Put aside the shocking falsity of Mr. Bush’s claim: Do pictures lie?
American forces have, are, and, if VP of torture Dick Cheney manages
to bully the Senate, will continue to torture, abusing
constitutional, civil, and physical rights of detainees during our
deluded, shotgun “war on terror.”
Put aside that George Bush, the most uncurious, bunkered president
in ages, appears not to ask the right questions of the right people
(starting with his own staff!). Who exactly is left to tell the
president whether his government agents torture or not, nor explain
the basic distinction between barbaric, “cruel and inhuman” torture
vs. proposed emergency tactics no worse than “degrading” or abusive?
Thus, even if the president had moral stature to deny torture, how
many Americans remain willing to believe one more Bush lie? Who many
of us would have confidence Bush would know about torturne one way
or the other? General Karpinski, the scapegoat who oversaw Abu
Ghraib, the worst kind of national scar thanks to graphic photos,
asserts Pentagon officials had to know, even condone torture and
So who has a clue what Bush knows – or cares about? Certainly no
staffer wants to explain to anyone, to reverse the historic
Watergate question, “what does the president NOT know and for how
long hasn’t he known it.” One senses, after the Libby indictment,
what Bush doesn’t know about his own White House would fille
So, the president’s credibility and moral stature aside, I have only
one question about “We do not torture.” To adapt a line from the
movie “The Wild Bunch” (“Who the hell is they?” referring to
anonymous agents of disaster), I ask: “Who the hell is we”?
Distinct from numberless administration outrages (an insurgency in
its “last throes”), this whopper alienated me in a new way.
Certainly, one expects spin, especially after the manipulated war
frenzy against Saddam Hussein has been stymied for years by
ill-trained, backalley insurgents searching out explosives in caves
or under rocks.
One deals with truth as the first victim of war, even an
administration which wars on truth – and, sadely, with more notable
success at home than in battle. Failures require more spin than
normal, but where does the president get off daring to speak for
“we”? 60% of Americans no longer believe he’s honest, let alone
justified in wasting American lives in Iraq.
Is it not time to draw the line and say here and now: Bush does
torture, even on Americans. I feel tortured by the wrong war in the
wrong place, daily death counts, and now a president daring to speak
for all of us, as if the manipulated election was a true mandate!
So, here’s my ultimatum. You want to lie, Mr. President, do it in
your terms and about things you know something. Stop lying in our
name. You probably will remain president for three more years, so is
too much to demand: speak for yourself, not the growing majority who
cringe when you pop up on TV or feel profound embarrassment when you
bully less powerful nations?
Where’s the silent majority when we need it, ready to again defend
America as the beacon of freedom, not beacon of torture, brute
power, and demonstrably false statements? One dreads tomorrow’s
news, for example, whole countries secretly taken over by the CIA to
house suspect detainees.
So, Mr. President, if you want to torture the truth and the English
language and majority will, stick to your own terms. Otherwise, you
abuse and degrade loyal Americans who never endorsed your invasion
and are horrified by a war America will certainly lose, just as it
lost in Vietnam, both in the field and in the world of public
Again, borrowing from Hollywood, I say: count me out. I even dream
of the day I can tell my children (or grandchildren), “We don’t do
Robert S. Becker, Ph.D., free-lance writer -
(In accordance with Title 17
U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed without profit to
those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the
included information for research and educational purposes.
Information Clearing House has no affiliation whatsoever with the
originator of this article nor is Information Clearing House
endorsed or sponsored by the originator.)