37 million poor hidden in the land of plenty
Americans have always believed that hard work will bring
rewards, but vast numbers now cannot meet their bills even with
two or three jobs. More than one in 10 citizens live below the
poverty line, and the gap between the haves and have-nots is
By Paul Harris in Kentucky
02/19/06 "The Observer" -- -- The flickering television in Candy Lumpkins's trailer blared out The Bold and the Beautiful. It was
a fantasy daytime soap vision of American life with little
relevance to the reality of this impoverished corner of
The Lumpkins live at the definition of the back of beyond, in a
hollow at the top of a valley at the end of a long and muddy
dirt road. It is strewn with litter. Packs of stray dogs prowl
around, barking at strangers. There is no telephone and since
their pump broke two weeks ago Candy has collected water from
nearby springs. Oblivious to it all, her five-year-old daughter
Amy runs barefoot on a wooden porch frozen by a midwinter chill.
It is a vision of deep and abiding poverty. Yet the Lumpkins are
not alone in their plight. They are just the negative side of
the American equation. America does have vast, wealthy suburbs,
huge shopping malls and a busy middle class, but it also has
vast numbers of poor, struggling to make it in a low-wage
economy with minimal government help.
A shocking 37 million Americans live in poverty. That is 12.7
per cent of the population - the highest percentage in the
developed world. They are found from the hills of Kentucky to
Detroit's streets, from the Deep South of Louisiana to the
heartland of Oklahoma. Each year since 2001 their number has
Under President George W Bush an extra 5.4 million have slipped
below the poverty line. Yet they are not a story of the
unemployed or the destitute. Most have jobs. Many have two. Amos
Lumpkins has work and his children go to school. But the
economy, stripped of worker benefits like healthcare, is having
trouble providing good wages.
Even families with two working parents are often one slice of
bad luck - a medical bill or factory closure - away from
disaster. The minimum wage of $5.15 (£2.95) an hour has not
risen since 1997 and, adjusted for inflation, is at its lowest
since 1956. The gap between the haves and the have-nots looms
wider than ever. Faced with rising poverty rates, Bush's
trillion-dollar federal budget recently raised massive amounts
of defence spending for the war in Iraq and slashed billions
from welfare programmes.
For a brief moment last year in New Orleans, Hurricane Katrina
brought America's poor into the spotlight. Poverty seemed on the
government's agenda. That spotlight has now been turned off. 'I
had hoped Katrina would have changed things more. It hasn't,'
says Cynthia Duncan, a sociology professor at the University of
Oklahoma is in America's heartland. Tulsa looks like
picture-book Middle America. Yet there is hunger here. When it
comes to the most malnourished poor in America, Oklahoma is
ahead of any other state. It should be impossible to go hungry
here. But it is not. Just ask those gathered at a food handout
last week. They are a cross section of society: black, white,
young couples, pensioners and the middle-aged. A few are out of
work or retired, everyone else has jobs.
They are people like Freda Lee, 33, who has two jobs, as a
marketer and a cashier. She has come to the nondescript Loaves
and Fishes building - flanked ironically by a Burger King and a
McDonald's - to collect food for herself and three sons.
'America is meant to be free. What's free?' she laughs. 'All we
can do is pay off the basics.'
Or they are people like Tammy Reinbold, 37. She works part-time
and her husband works full-time. They have two children yet rely
on the food handouts. 'The church is all we have to fall back
on,' she says. She is right. When government help is being cut
and wages are insufficient, churches often fill the gap. The
needy gather to receive food boxes. They listen to a preacher
for half an hour on the literal truth of the Bible. Then he asks
them if they want to be born again. Three women put up their
But why are some Tulsans hungry?
Many believe it is the changing face of the US economy. Tulsa
has been devastated by job losses. Big-name firms like WorldCom,
Williams Energy and CitGo have closed or moved, costing the city
about 24,000 jobs. Now Wal-Mart embodies the new American job
market: low wages, few benefits.
Well-paid work only goes to the university-educated. Many others
who just complete high school face a bleak future. In Texas more
than a third of students entering public high schools now drop
out. These people are entering the fragile world of the working
poor, where each day is a mere step away from tragedy. Some of
those tragedies in Tulsa end up in the care of Steve Whitaker, a
pastor who runs a homeless mission in the shadow of a freeway
Each day the homeless and the drug addicted gather here, looking
for a bed for the night. Some also want a fresh chance. They are
men like Mark Schloss whose disaster was being left by his first
wife. The former Wal-Mart manager entered a world of drug
addiction and alcoholism until he wound up with Whitaker. Now he
is back on track, sporting a silver ring that says Faith, Hope,
Love. 'Without this place I would be in prison or dead,' he
says. But Whitaker equates saving lives with saving souls. Those
entering the mission's rehabilitation programme are drilled in
Bible studies and Christianity. At 6ft 5in and with a black belt
in karate, Whitaker's Christianity is muscular both literally
and figuratively. 'People need God in their lives,' he says.
These are mean streets. Tulsa is a city divided like the
country. Inside a building run by Whitaker's staff in northern
Tulsa a group of 'latch-key kids' are taking Bible classes after
school while they wait for parents to pick them up. One of them
is Taylor Finley, aged nine. Wearing a T-shirt with an American
flag on the front, she dreams of travel. 'I want to have fun in
a new place, a new country,' she says. Taylor wants to see the
world outside Oklahoma. But at the moment she cannot even see
her own neighbourhood. The centre in which she waits for mom was
built without windows on its ground floor. It was the only way
to keep out bullets from the gangs outside.
During the 2004 election the only politician to address poverty
directly was John Edwards, whose campaign theme was 'Two
Americas'. He was derided by Republicans for doing down the
country and - after John Kerry picked him as his Democratic
running mate - the rhetoric softened in the heat of the
But, in fact, Edwards was right. While 45.8 million Americans
lack any health insurance, the top 20 per cent of earners take
over half the national income. At the same time the bottom 20
per cent took home just 3.4 per cent. Whitaker put the figures
into simple English. 'The poor have got poorer and the rich have
got richer,' he said.
Dealing with poverty is not a viable political issue in America.
It jars with a cultural sense that the poor bring things upon
themselves and that every American is born with the same chances
in life. It also runs counter to the strong anti-government
current in modern American politics. Yet the problem will not
disappear. 'There is a real sense of impending crisis, but
political leaders have little motivation to address this growing
divide,' Cynthia Duncan says.
There is little doubt which side of America's divide the hills
of east Kentucky fall on. Driving through the wooded Appalachian
valleys is a lesson in poverty. The mountains have never been
rich. Times now are as tough as they have ever been. Trailer
homes are the norm. Every so often a lofty mansion looms into
view, a sign of prosperity linked to the coal mines or the
logging firms that are the only industries in the region.
Everyone else lives on the margins, grabbing work where they
can. The biggest cash crop is illicitly grown marijuana.
Save The Children works here. Though the charity is usually
associated with earthquakes in Pakistan or famine in Africa, it
runs an extensive programme in east Kentucky. It includes a
novel scheme enlisting teams of 'foster grandparents' to tackle
the shocking child illiteracy rates and thus eventually hit
The problem is acute. At Jone's Fork school, a team of
indomitable grannies arrive each day to read with the children.
The scheme has two benefits: it helps the children struggle out
of poverty and pays the pensioners a small wage. 'This has been
a lifesaver for me and I feel as if the children would just fall
through the cracks without us,' says Erma Owens. It has offered
dramatic help to some. One group of children are doing so well
in the scheme that their teacher, Loretta Shepherd, has
postponed retirement in order to stand by them. 'It renewed me
to have these kids,' she said.
Certainly Renae Sturgill sees the changes in her children. She
too lives in deep poverty. Though she attends college and her
husband has a job, the Sturgill trailer sits amid a clutter of
abandoned cars. Money is scarce. But now her kids are in the
reading scheme and she has seen how they have changed.
Especially eight-year-old Zach. He's hard to control at times,
but he has come to love school. 'Zach likes reading now. I know
it's going to be real important for him,' Renae says. Zach is
shy and won't speak much about his achievements. But Genny
Waddell, who co-ordinates family welfare at Jone's Fork, is
immensely proud. 'Now Zach reads because he wants to. He really
fought to get where he is,' she says.
In America, to be poor is a stigma. In a country which
celebrates individuality and the goal of giving everyone an
equal opportunity to make it big, those in poverty are often
blamed for their own situation. Experience on the ground does
little to bear that out. When people are working two jobs at a
time and still failing to earn enough to feed their families, it
seems impossible to call them lazy or selfish. There seems to be
a failure in the system, not the poor themselves.
It is an impression backed up by many of those mired in poverty
in Oklahoma and Kentucky. Few asked for handouts. Many asked for
decent wages. 'It is unfair. I am working all the time and so
what have I done wrong?' says Freda Lee. But the economy does
not seem to be allowing people to make a decent living. It
condemns the poor to stay put, fighting against seemingly
impossible odds or to pull up sticks and try somewhere else.
In Tulsa, Tammy Reinbold and her family are moving to Texas as
soon as they save the money for enough petrol. It could take
several months. 'I've been in Tulsa 12 years and I just gotta
try somewhere else,' she says.
From Tom Joad to Roseanne
In a country that prides itself on a culture of rugged
individualism, hard work and self-sufficiency, it is no surprise
that poverty and the poor do not have a central place in
America's cultural psyche.
But in art, films and books American poverty has sometimes been
portrayed with searing honesty. John Steinbeck's novel The
Grapes of Wrath, which was made into a John Ford movie, is the
most famous example. It was an unflinching account of the
travails of a poor Oklahoma family forced to flee the Dust Bowl
during the 1930s Depression. Its portrait of Tom Joad and his
family's life on the road as they sought work was a nod to wider
issues of social justice in America.
Another ground-breaking work of that time was John Agee's Let Us
Now Praise Famous Men, a non-fiction book about time spent among
poor white farmers in the Deep South. It practically disappeared
upon its first publication in 1940 but in the Sixties was hailed
as a masterpiece. In mainstream American culture, poverty often
lurks in the background. Or it is portrayed - as in Sergio
Leone's crime epic Once Upon A Time In America - as the basis
for a tale of rags to riches.
One notable, yet often overlooked, exception was the great
success of the sitcom Roseanne. The show depicted the realities
of working-class Middle American life with a grit and humour
that is a world away from the usual sitcom settings in a sunlit
suburbia, most often in New York or California. The biggest
sitcoms of the past decade - Friends, Frasier or Will and Grace
- all deal with aspirational middle-class foibles that have
little relevance to America's millions of working poor.
An America divided
· There are 37 million Americans living below the poverty line.
That figure has increased by five million since President George
W. Bush came to power.
· The United States has 269 billionaires, the highest number in
· Almost a quarter of all black Americans live below the poverty
line; 22 per cent of Hispanics fall below it. But for whites the
figure is just 8.6 per cent.
· There are 46 million Americans without health insurance.
· There are 82,000 homeless people in Los Angeles alone.
· In 2004 the poorest community in America was Pine Ridge Indian
reservation. Unemployment is over 80 per cent, 69 per cent of
people live in poverty and male life expectancy is 57 years. In
the Western hemisphere only Haiti has a lower number.
· The richest town in America is Rancho Santa Fe in California.
Average incomes are more than $100,000 a year; the average house
price is $1.7m.
© Guardian Newspapers Limited 2006
(In accordance with Title 17
U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed without profit to
those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the
included information for research and educational purposes.
Information Clearing House has no affiliation whatsoever with the
originator of this article nor is Information Clearing House
endorsed or sponsored by the originator.)