Victims of War Are Not To Be Seen Or Heard Or Mentioned
"The greatest dignity and respect you can give [victims of war]
is to show the horror they suffered, the absolute gruesome
horror." -War Photographer David Lesson
By Robert Weitzel
Joseph Bonham was an American soldier. He lost both of his arms
and legs and all of his face to an artillery shell. He could not
see or hear or speak. Other than that he was healthy and lucid.
That was Joe's nightmare. He could be kept alive a long time.
Joe remained an anonymous torso until his head tapping was
recognized as Morse code. When his message was finally
understood, it was assumed he'd gone insane. Joe asked to be put
on exhibit so that children and parents and teachers and
politicians and preachers and patriots of every stripe could
have a close-up look at war's leavings. It was the only way he
could give his nightmare meaning.
Joseph Bonham's request was denied. It was not in the best
interest of the country to foist him on an unsuspecting public.
He died an "unknown soldier."
On March 18, 2003, two days before her son launched the invasion
of Iraq, Barbara Bush appeared on Good Morning America. Our
nation's "First Mother" asked Diane Sawyer, "Why should we hear
about body bags and death and how many? . . . Oh, I mean, it's
not relevant. So why should I waste my beautiful mind on
something like that."
First Mother Bush knows her children well. When it comes to
war's gallery of death and grotesqueries the big difference
between Joseph Bonham and ourselves is that we choose not to see
or hear or speak.
We resist and resent any reminder of the human cost of war with
epithets and accusations. It is a breech of good taste. It
undermines morale on the home front. It is aiding and abetting
the enemy. It is unpatriotic and irrelevant. It is a waste of
our beautiful minds.
In November 2004 Travis Babbitt was mortally wounded while on
patrol in Baghdad. An Associated Press photographer captured his
last moments on film. When the Star Ledger of Newark, N. J. and
several other papers published the picture their editors were
excoriated by readers who called them "cruel, insensitive, even
Defending the decision to print the photograph, Star Ledger's
assistant managing editor, Pim Van Hemmen wrote, "Writing a
headline that 1,500 Americans have died doesn't give you nearly
the impact of showing one serviceman who died."
Six months after the publication of the picture Babbitt's mother
told a Los Angles Times reporter, "That is not an image you want
to see like that. Your kid is lying like that and there is no
way you can get there to help them. I do think it's an important
thing, for people to see what goes on over there. It throws
reality more in your face. And sometimes we can't help reality"
In war soldiers and civilians die gruesome deaths and suffer
horrific wounds. This is reality. Pictures that capture this
miserable fact are not meant to be gratuitously violent. They
are merely the unvarnished truth.
Veteran war photographer, Chris Hondros, admits that many of his
imagines of war are indeed horrible, but says, " . . . war is
horrible and we need to understand that. I think if we are going
to start a war, we ought to be willing to show the consequences
of that war."
But it is not only the dying that remains invisible and unheard
and never mentioned. The armless and the legless and the blind
and the burned, the destroyed minds and the disfigured bodies
"recovering" at Walter Reed Army Hospital remain as unknown as
Joseph Bonham. The national myths and political lies that sent
these casualties marching to war cannot abide their wounds.
Joseph Bonham lived in the fictional world of Dalton Trumbo's
antiwar novel, "johnny got his gun." But the victims of war are
flesh and blood. They have weight. Their lives are counted in
years. We cannot turn them into a work of fiction and then
refuse to even look at what we have written.
March 20 is the third anniversary of the start of the "The Long
War" (formerly the War on Terror) in Iraq. It has cost America
more than 340,650 pounds of flesh and bone and viscera, 2,838
gallons of blood, 6,813 pounds of brain matter, and 113,550
unlived years. It has cost Iraq over 18 million pounds of flesh
and bone and viscera, 125,000 gallons of blood, 300,000 pounds
of brain matter, and 5 million unlived years.
Imagine if we could see this . . . one picture at a time.
On January 31, 2006, Cindy Sheehan, whose son was killed in
Iraq, appeared in the gallery of the House of Representatives to
hear President Bush's State of the Union address. She was
manhandled, shunted from view, and arrested for wearing a
t-shirt that displayed the number of American war dead and that
asked, "How many more?"
Robert Weitzel lives in Middleton, WI. His essays regularly
appear in The Capital Times in Madison, WI. He has also been
published in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Skeptic Magazine,
Freethought Today, and on the web sites, smirkingchimp.com and
talkreason.org. He can be contacted at:
(In accordance with Title 17
U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed without profit to
those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the
included information for research and educational purposes.
Information Clearing House has no affiliation whatsoever with the
originator of this article nor is Information Clearing House
endorsed or sponsored by the originator.)