05/07/03: (London
Times) THE continuing failure to find Saddam
Hussein’s weapons of mass destruction has triggered a
blame game in America’s intelligence agencies that
erupted into public view yesterday.
As the hunt continues for Iraq’s alleged stockpiles
of chemical and biological weapons — the main
justification cited by President Bush for the war —
carefully placed leaks revealed deep misgivings inside
the CIA over intelligence used by the White House to
make its case against Saddam.
Present and former CIA officials, quoted in The
New York Times and The New Yorker magazine,
claimed that a small number of powerful neo-conservative
ideologues in the Pentagon were so determined to prove
the existence of a banned weapons programme and links to
al-Qaeda that they manipulated intelligence.
According to a report written by Seymour Hersh, the
veteran New Yorker investigative reporter, the
Pentagon’s Office of Special Plans (OSP) relied too
heavily on suspect intelligence provided by Iraqi
defectors with links to the Iraqi National Congress, an
opposition group headed by Ahmad Chalabi, an Iraqi
exile.
Mr Hersh reported that intelligence gathered by the
OSP drove the war agenda, often in the face of evidence
that it was either unreliable or false. The OSP reported
to Paul Wolfowitz, the Deputy Defence Secretary and a
leading proponent of the war.
One former CIA official told Mr Hersh: “One of the
reasons I left was my sense that they (OSP) were using
the intelligence from the CIA and other agencies only
when it fits their agenda. They were so crazed and so
far out and so difficult to reason with . . . as if they
were on a mission from God. If it doesn’t fit their
theory, they don’t want to accept it.”
Mr Hersh maintained that key intelligence provided by
Iraqi defectors with links to the Iraqi National
Congress was disputed by the CIA.
He cited as one example the evidence of Adnan Ihsan
Said al-Haideri, a civil engineer who fled Iraq in 2001
with the National Congress’s help. Mr al-Haideri, Mr
Hersh said, was apparently the source for the assertion
by Colin Powell, the Secretary of State, in his speech
to the UN Security Council that the US had “first-hand
descriptions” of hidden mobile chemical and biological
factories. The 20 claimed sites have been examined by UN
inspectors and US forces and no trace of banned weapons
facilities was found.
Patrick Lang, a former head of Middle Eastern affairs
in the Pentagon’s Defence Intelligence agency, told
Nicholas Kristof, of The New York Times, that
when experts wrote reports sceptical about the existence
of weapons of mass destruction “they were encouraged
to think it over again”.
Saddam Hussein is alleged to call on Iraqis to rise
up against US-led forces in Iraq in a cassette said to
have been recorded this week, an Australian newspaper
reported.
In the recording, delivered to Sydney Morning
Herald journalists in Baghdad, a
“tired-sounding” voice said: “We have to go back
to the secret style of struggle that we began our life
with . . . your main task is to kick the enemy out from
our country.” The newspaper played the tape to 13
Iraqis, including a former acquaintance of Saddam, and
“the overwhelming opinion was that the voice and
rhetoric were very similar, or identical, to those of
Saddam”.