.

Post-War Iraq Quiz
by Stephen R. Shalom
- The Bush administration claimed that it waged war on Iraq because
of its concern about terrorism. How else has the administration
shown its concern about terrorism?
- Though there are more than 100 chemical plants where a single
terrorist attack could potentially expose more than a million
people to toxic gas, there are no mandatory security regulations
applying to chemical plants. Tough legislation in this regard was
blocked by industry lobbying and lack of support from the Bush
administration.
- It was not until 18 months after 9/11 that the Nuclear
Regulatory Agency revised its policy stating that nuclear power
plants needed to be secure only from an attack by three or fewer
individuals armed with no more than rifles; the revisions were
worked out in closed-door meetings with the nuclear industry and
excluded public interest organizations. The new policy is secret,
but NRC officials are on record as saying it is not necessary to
be able to protect against a 9/11-scale attack.
- The Bush administration has ordered the elimination of 11% of
airport baggage screener jobs.
- All of the above.
- Presidential Press Secretary Ari Fleischer declared on April 10
"we have high confidence that they have weapons of mass
destruction. That is what this war was about and it is about. And we
have high confidence it will be found." Which of the following
has been a result of the hunt for weapons of mass destruction in
Iraq?
- Before the war, the Bush administration warned that Iraq might
have 25,000 liters of anthrax, 38,000 liters of botulinum toxin,
500 tons of sarin, mustard and VX nerve agent, and upwards of
30,000 munitions capable of delivering chemical agents. So far,
these estimates have fallen short by exactly 25,000 liters of
anthrax, 38,000 liters of botulinum toxin, 500 tons of sarin,
mustard and VX nerve agent, and 30,000 munitions capable of
delivering chemical agents.
- Despite the claim that the war was fought to prevent WMD getting
into the hands of terrorists, U.S. officials allowed the looting
of seven sites in Iraq where nuclear material was present.
- U.S. troops found a "top secret" Iraqi intelligence
memo at a secret police headquarters that described an offer by a
"holy warrior" in Africa to sell uranium and other
nuclear material to Iraq. Iraq rejected the offer, the
memo states, because of the United Nations "sanctions
situation."
- All of the above.
- U.S. officials warned that Saddam Hussein's forces were prepared
to use chemical weapons during the war. Which of the following
describes the actual conduct of the war?
- The United States and Britain used cluster bombs, condemned by
international human rights groups.
- The only time "coalition" forces had to wear their
protective chemical suits during the war was when recovering a
body from a friendly fire incident to protect themselves from the
effects of U.S. depleted uranium ordnance.
- The United States and Britain used depleted uranium munitions,
which Amnesty International urges be banned until their long-term
health effects can be properly investigated and which the European
Parliament urges be banned pending a comprehensive study of their
legality.
- All of the above.
- The Bush administration claimed that war against Iraq would
somehow diminish the danger from al Qaeda. What is the al Qaeda
threat today?
- The International Institute for Strategic Studies concluded in
May 2003 that al Qaeda was "more insidious and just as
dangerous" as it was before September 11, 2001.
- Jason Burke, author of a forthcoming book on al Qaeda, has
written "That the conflict in Iraq led to a rise in
recruitment for radical groups is now so clear that even US
officials admit it. This is a huge setback in the 'war on
terror.'"
- Rohan Gunaratna, an expert on al Qaeda, said al Qaeda had been
weakened, but it had no trouble in recruiting fresh members among
Muslims whose anti-Western passions had been fuelled by the war in
Iraq. "For every three to five members, they have five to 10
more recruits. As a result, active terrorist groups will be able
to grow and become more powerful and influential."
- All of the above.
- U.S. officials claimed that there were ties between Saddam Hussein
and al Qaeda. What evidence has come to light supporting this claim?
- Senior U.S. intelligence officials acknowledge that they have
not yet found any new and conclusive evidence inside Iraq of
connections between Saddam Hussein's government and al Qaeda.
- U.S. intelligence officials have told journalist Seymour Hersh
that the Boeing 707 parked at Salman Pak outside Baghdad was not,
as U.S. spokespeople have charged, for training terrorists in
airplane hijacking, but for training in anti-hijacking operations.
- Despite a much ballyhooed document said to be found by a
reporter - after the CIA had gone through the building and
"seemed to have missed" it - showing that an envoy from
bin Laden visited Baghdad in 1998, British intelligence remained
doubtful that any working relationship was established and noted
the lack of any evidence of any follow up meetings.
- All of the above.
- The Bush administration claimed that this war would teach nations
not to seek weapons of mass destruction. What is the state of
proliferation in the wake of the Iraq war?
- "Paradoxically, the runaway American victory in the
conventional arms race might inspire a new round of proliferation
of atomic weapons. With no hope of matching the United States
plane for plane, more countries may seek atomic weapons to gain
deterrence."
- At the international disarmament conference that began in late
April 2003 in Geneva, "disarmament experts said that American
lack of commitment to non-proliferation was as damaging as the
behavior of the proliferators."
- On April 24, shortly after the fall of Baghdad, North Korea
announced that it possessed nuclear weapons.
- All of the above.
- The U.S. war on Iraq involved no mass slaughter as in Hiroshima or
Dresden. Which of the following indicates the impact of the war on
Iraqi civilians?
- According to the documented, but necessarily incomplete
tabulations of Iraq Body Count, at least 5,400 civilians have been
killed in Iraq by U.S.-led military action between March 21 and
May 26.
- UNICEF reported that acute malnutrition rates in children under
5 had doubled from before the war.
- According to Kadem Hashem, a resident of Nasariya, "Before,
we had no freedom, but we had security. Now, we have freedom, but
no security, no work and no income."
- All of the above.
- The looting of Iraqi museums, hospitals, universities, and
government ministries while U.S. troops stood by is well known. What
other looting of Iraq has been taking place?
- Halliburton, formerly headed by and still paying Vice President
Dick Cheney, which was fined $2 million to resolve fraud claims in
2002, and which has given $674,000 in campaign contributions to
Republicans from 1999-2002, was awarded by the Pentagon a secret,
no-bid contract for work in Iraq worth as much as $7 billion.
- Bechtel, whose former chief executive and current board member
is George Shultz, Reagan's Secretary of State and head of the
advisory committee of the Committee to Liberate Iraq, whose
current CEO is on Bush's Export Council, whose other current or
former board members include Reagan's Secretary of Defense and CIA
director and a member of Bush's Defense Policy Board, which has
given $766,000 in campaign contributions to Republicans from
1999-2002, and which tried to work out a pipeline deal with Saddam
Hussein in the early 1980s with the help of emissary Donald
Rumsfeld, was awarded the largest Iraq reconstruction contract by
USAID.
- The U.S.-appointed chair of the U.S.-established
"advisory" committee for the Iraqi oil industry, Philip
J. Carroll, former head of Shell Oil and of Fluor (a firm
currently bidding on Iraq reconstruction projects) and with
substantial stock in both, has indicated that Iraq might
"choose" not to remain within OPEC, which would serve
the U.S. aim of breaking the oil cartel. The one near-certainty,
said Carroll, is that the future expansion of Iraq's oil industry
will be driven in part by foreign capital.
- All of the above.
- The end of Saddam Hussein's dictatorship is extremely welcome. Yet
which of the following might indicate that democracy is not on the
immediate horizon for Iraq?
- On April 28, the U.S. and Britain organized a meeting in Baghdad
to start the political process. Many parties were not invited, and
though U.S. and UK authorities refused to provide a list of
invitees it was known that the two largest pre-Saddam Hussein
parties - the Communist party and the Islamic Dawa party - were
excluded, while outside thousands protested.
- The U.S. Office of Reconstruction and Humanitarian Assistance -
the formal occupying authority - is so lacking in transparency
that even its charter remains classified secret.
- The formation of the Iraqi interim authority -- which U.S.
officials made clear would not be an interim government,
for Washington would retain the crucial levers of power for an
indefinite period -- has been postponed by the U.S. until July at
the earliest.
- All of the above.
- Attorney General John Ashcroft has replied to critics who warn
that his policies threaten civil liberties, "To those who scare
peace-loving people with phantoms of lost liberty, my message to you
is this: Your tactics only aid terrorists." Which of the
following have been aiding terrorists?
- The 31% of corporate chief security officers surveyed by CSO
magazine who believe that the United States is in jeopardy of
becoming a police state.
- Leading conservative ideologue and former House majority leader
Dick Armey, who called the Justice Department "out of
control" and "the most dangerous agency of
government."
- The Republican-majority State legislature of Alaska, which
passed with a single dissenting vote a resolution condemning the
Patriot Act.
- All of the above.
- Match the quotations in column one with the person who said them
in column two.
- "We came to bear country, we came loaded for bear
and we found out the bear wasn't here."
- "The Iraqis are sick people and we are the
chemotherapy. I am starting to hate this country. Wait
till I get hold of a friggin' Iraqi. No, I won't get hold
of one. I'll just kill him."
- "We're going to ask people to turn up to the
buildings even if they don't exist."
- "It's no coincidence that no terrorist operations
were mounted by al Qaeda. This was the big game for them
-- you put up or shut up and they have failed. It proves
that the global war on terrorism has been effective,
focused and has got these guys on the run."
- "[T]his was not the primary reason we went to war.
We emphasized the danger of Saddam's weapons … in order
to gain legal justification for war from the United
Nations and to emphasize the danger here at home to our
own people. We were not lying … 'it was just a matter of
emphasis.'"
- "Saddam Hussein is a terrible person, he is a
threat to his own people. I think his people would be
better off with a different leader, but there is this sort
of romantic notion that if Saddam Hussein got hit by a bus
tomorrow, some Jeffersonian democrat is waiting in the
wings to hold popular elections. You're going to get --
guess what -- probably another Saddam Hussein. It will
take a little while for them to paint the pictures all
over the walls again -- but there should be no illusions
about the nature of that country or its society. And the
American people and all of the people who second-guess us
now would have been outraged if we had gone on to Baghdad
and we found ourselves in Baghdad with American soldiers
patrolling the streets two years later still looking for
Jefferson."
- "Stuff happens."
- "We have entered World War IV. More than a war
against terrorism, this is a war to extend democracy to
those parts of the Arab and Muslim world that threaten the
liberal civilization we worked to build and defend
throughout the 20th century . . . . I hope it will not be
as long as the 40-plus years of World War III but it will
certainly be longer than either World War I or World War
II. It will probably take decades."
|
- A Defense Intelligence Agency officer from Task Force
75, the group charged with finding weapons of mass
destruction in Iraq, on closing up shop after finding no
such weapons.
- A U.S. marine, after his unit killed 12 Iraqi civilians.
- Maj. Gen. Carl Strock of the Army Corps of Engineers at
a news conference explaining that Iraqi civil servants
were being asked to return to work even in cases where
there were no facilities left because of looting.
- Cofer Black, long-time CIA terrorism official who now
heads the State Department's counterterrorism office, a
week before al Qaeda attacks in Saudi Arabia and Morocco.
- Unnamed U.S. officials, quoted by ABC News, asked the
significance if no weapons of mass destruction are found
in Iraq.
- Colin Powell, chair of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, 1992.
- Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, explaining why
U.S. forces had not prevented looting in Iraq.
- James Woolsey, former CIA director and current Pentagon
adviser, indicating his broader agenda.
- Mohammed Saeed al-Sahaf, Saddam Hussein's Minister of
Information.
|
Answers and Sources
- (D)
- Jacob M. Schlesinger and Thaddeus Herrick, "Chemical
Manufacturers Elude Crackdown On Toxic Materials," Wall
Street Journal, May 21, 2003, available on Sen.
Corzine's website; U.S. General Accounting Office, Voluntary
Initiatives Are Under Way at Chemical Facilities but the Extent
of Security Preparedness Is Unknown, GAO-03-439, March
2003.
- Daniel Hirsch, David Lochbaum & Edwin Lyman, "The
NRC's Dirty Little Secret," Bulletin of the Atomic
Scientists, May/June 2003, pp. 44-51; Committee To Bridge
The Gap, Nuclear Control Institute, and Union Of Concerned
Scientists, press release, "Nuclear Terrorism Experts
Criticize NRC's 'Mini-Steps' On Reactor Security; 'Minimal
Changes Are Insufficient To Protect Against 9/11-Type
Threats,'" May 1, 2003, [link];
Bennett Ramberg, "Safety or Secrecy," New York
Times (NYT), May 20, 2003, p. A27.
- Ricardo Alonso-Zaldivar, "Amid Criticism, U.S. Will Cut
11% of Airport Screener Jobs," Los Angeles Times (LAT),
May 1, 2003, p. I:18; Ron Marsico, "Senators fault plans to
cut screeners at Newark Airport," Newark Star Ledger,
May 17, 2003; Edward Wong, "Security Cutbacks Worry Airport
Officials," NYT, May 22, 2003, p. C1.
- (D) White House Press Briefing, April 10, 2003, [link].
- Administration claims from George W. Bush, State of the Union
message, Jan. 28, 2003, [link].
- Barton Gellman, "Seven Nuclear Sites Looted; Iraqi
Scientific Files, Some Containers Missing," Washington
Post (WP), May 10, 2003, p. A01; Donald Macintyre,
"In the Wreckage of Saddam's Nuclear Research Centre,
Looters Take Their Pick of Lethal Spoils," Independent,
May 10, 2003, p. 4; Walter Pincus, "U.N. Atomic Chief Again
Warns U.S. About Iraq," WP, May 20, 2003, p. A08.
Note: there is no evidence that these were weapons sites; their
nuclear material had been under international supervision and
seal.
- This rather significant document was referred to only in the
middle of a long article on unrelated documents dealing with
Israel and hence has gone largely unnoticed. Judith Miller,
"Iraqi Documents on Israel Surface on a Cultural
Hunt," NYT, May 7, 2003, p. A17.
- (D)
- See Amnesty International, "Iraq: Use of cluster bombs --
Civilians pay the price," April 2, 2003, [link];
Human Rights Watch, "U.S. Use of Clusters in Baghdad
Condemned," April 16, 2003, [link].
See also Iraq Body Count, "How Many Civilians Were Killed
By Cluster Bombs? The Pentagon says 1: Iraq Body Count says at
least 200," May 2003, [link].
- Audrey Gillian, "'I never want to hear that sound again':
Five British soldiers have died under 'friendly fire,'" Guardian,
March 31, 2003, p. 3.
- Amnesty International, "Iraq: Voice your opposition to
indiscriminate weapons - Take action!" April 4, 2003, [link];
European Parliament, "Unexploded ordnance and depleted
uranium ammunition," Feb. 13, 2003, P5_TA-PROV(2003)0062,
available at [link].
- (D)
- Michael Evans, "Al-Qaeda is now 'as great a threat as it
was before September 11'," The Times (London), May
14, 2003, p. 16.
- Jason Burke, "The return of al Qaeda," Observer,
May 18, 2003, p. 17. See also "Iraq war helped boost Al
Qaeda," Toronto Star, May 20, 2003, p. A01.
- Robin Gedye, "Al-Qa'eda 'getting ready to strike
back'," Daily Telegraph, May 22, 2003, p. 4.
- (D)
- James Risen, "Prewar Views of Iraq Threat Are Under
Review by C.I.A.," NYT, May 22, 2003, p. A1.
- Seymour Hersh, "Selective Intelligence," New
Yorker, May 12, 2003.
- Martin Bright and Jason Burke, "Saddam held talks on
alliance with al-Qaeda," Observer, April 27, 2003,
p. 2; Donald Macintyre, "Intelligence Papers Found In
Baghdad Point To Regime's Links With Bin Laden," Independent,
April 28, 2003, p. 9; Michael Evans, "Saddam link to al-Qaeda
in doubt," The Times (London), April 28, 2003, p.
14; Richard Norton-Taylor and Ewen MacAskill, "Al-Qaida
links still dubious," Guardian, April 28, 2003, p.
11.
- (D)
- Gregg Easterbrook, "American Power Moves Beyond the Mere
Super," NYT, April 27, 2003, p. IV:1.
- Peter Popham, "Nuclear War Risk Grows As States Race To
Acquire Bomb," Independent, April 29, 2003, p. 13.
The U.S. lack of commitment has been demonstrated by Bush's
signing of Presidential National Security Directive 17 saying
that the U.S. reserves the right to use nuclear weapons against
a non-nuclear weapons state (in violation of Security Council
resolution 984 of 1995), by its refusal to ratify the
Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, and by the Pentagon's
request to have Congress lift the 10-year ban on developing
small nuclear warheads. (See Julian Borger, "Pentagon wants
mini-nuke ban to be lifted," Guardian, March 7,
2003, p. 18.)
- David E. Sanger, "North Korea Says It Now Possesses
Nuclear Arsenal," NYT, April 25, 2003, p. A1.
- (D)
- http://www.iraqbodycount.net/,
accessed May 27, 2003 (sources and methodology included; a few
additional deaths before March 21 are also listed). See also
Laura King, "Baghdad's Death Toll Assessed," LAT,
May 18, 2003, p. I:1; Peter Ford, "Surveys pointing to high
civilian death toll in Iraq," Christian Science Monitor,
May 22, 2003, p. 1.
- UNICEF, "Iraq survey finds child health sliding,"
May 14, 2003, [link].
- Quoted in Ed Vulliamy, "Gun gangs rule streets as US
loses control," Observer, May 25, 2003.
- (D)
- David Ivanovich, "Pentagon defends Halliburton job; Firm
got contract without bids," Houston Chronicle,
April 11, 2003, Business section, p. 1; Minority Staff,
Committee on Government Reform, U.S. House of Representatives,
"Fact Sheet: The Bush Administration's Contracts With
Halliburton," May 2003, and letters, Robert B. Flowers to
Henry A. Waxman, May 2, 2003; Waxman to Flowers, May 6, 2003,
all available at [link];
Center For Responsive Politics, "Rebuilding Iraq,"
Updated 4/28/03, [link];
AP, "Papers Show Expanded Halliburton Iraq Role," NYT,
May 7, 2003, p. C13.
- Center For Responsive Politics, "Rebuilding Iraq,"
Updated 4/28/03, [link];
Jim Vallette, Steve Kretzmann, and Daphne Wysham, Crude
Vision: How Oil Interests Obscured U.S. Government Focus on
Chemical Weapons Use by Saddam Hussein, Washington, DC:
Institute for Policy Studies, March 2003; Andrew Gumbel,
"Well-Connected and Wealthy: Bechtel Wins from Saddam's
Demise," Independent, May 24, 2003, p. 10. The
administrator of USAID, Andrew Natsios, once headed the
Boston-area "Big Dig" construction project, for which
Bechtel was the prime contractor, with immense cost-over-runs.
- Peter S. Goodman, "U.S. Adviser Says Iraq May Break With
OPEC; Carroll Hints Nation Could Void Contracts," WP,
May 17, 2003, p. E1; Mark Fineman, "Advisor Cites Conflict
Potential," LAT, May 16, 2003, p. I:4.
- (D)
- Elizabeth Neuffer, "Iraqis OK Conference on Self-Rule
Critics Urge More Inclusion Next Month," Boston Globe,
April 29, 2003, p. 1; Jonathan Steele, "Delegates agree new
talks on government," Guardian, April 29, 2003, p.
4.
- Edward Epstein, "Congress curious about Iraq deals;
Members from both parties want details on awarding of
contracts," San Francisco Chronicle, May 20, 2003,
p. A3.
- Neela Banerjee, "U.S. Says Iraqi Assembly Could Meet in
July," NYT, May 22, 2003, p. A13; Edmund L.
Andrews, "Shiite Group Says U.S. Is Reneging on Interim
Rule," NYT, May 19, 2003, p. A10.
- (D) Ashcroft quoted: Neil A. Lewis, "Ashcroft Defends
Antiterror Plan; Says Criticism May Aid U.S. Foes," NYT,
Dec. 7, 2001, p. A1.
- CSO press release, "Chief Security Officers Reveal
Concerns About U.S. Government Security Measures," May 12,
2003, [link].
- Quoted in Nat Hentoff, "Conservatives Rise for the Bill
of Rights!" Village Voice, April 25, 2003, [link].
- Dean Schabner, "Northern Revolt: Alaska Passes
Anti-Patriot Act Resolution; Second State to Oppose Feds,"
ABC News, May 23, 2003, [link].
Text of Alaska's resolution is at [link].
Similar resolutions have been passed by the state of Hawaii and
by 112 cities, towns, and counties (as of May 27, 2003),
including Baltimore, Denver, Detroit, Hartford, Minneapolis, San
Francisco, Santa Fe, Seattle, and Tucson. See Bill
of Rights Defense Committee. Guidelines for working on such
resolutions are available at http://www.bordc.org.
For general analyses of the state of civil liberties in the
United States since 9/11, see American Civil Liberties Union, Freedom
Under Fire: Dissent in Post-9/11 America, New York: ACLU,
May 2003, http://www.aclu.org;
New York Civil Liberties Union, Arresting Protest: A Special
Report of the New York Civil Liberties Union on New York City's
Protest Policies at the February 15, 2003 Antiwar Demonstration
in New York City, New York: NYCLU, April, 2003, http://www.nyclu.org;
Lawyer's Committee for Human Rights, A Year of Loss:
Reexamining Civil Liberties Since September 11, New York:
LCHR, 2002, and Lawyer's Committee for Human Rights, Imbalance
of Powers: How Changes to U.S. Law & Policy Since 9/11 Erode
Human Rights and Civil Liberties, September 2002 - March 2003,
New York: LCHR, 2003, http://www.lchr.org.
-
- (i) Barton Gellman, "Frustrated, U.S. Arms Team to Leave
Iraq: Task Force Unable To Find Any Weapons," WP,
May 11, 2003, p. A1.
- (ii) Mark Franchetti, "US Marines Turn Fire on Civilians
at the Bridge of Death," The Times (London), March
30, 2003, p. 1.
- (iii) Jane Perlez and Michael R. Gordon, "Baghdad Blasts
At Arms Dump Kill at Least 6," NYT, April 27,
2003, p. I:1.
- (iv) Walter Pincus and Dana Priest, "Spy Agencies'
Optimism On Al Qaeda Is Growing; Lack of Attacks Thought to Show
Group Is Nearly Crippled," WP, May 6, 2003, p.
A16.
- (v) ABC News, Nightline, April 22, 2003, John Cochran
reporting.
- (vi) Quoted in Robert Blecher, "'Free People Will Set the
Course of History': Intellectuals, Democracy and American
Empire," Middle
East Report Online, March 2003.
- (vii) "Rumsfeld's Words on Iraq: 'There Is
Untidiness'," NYT, April 12, 2003, p. B5.
- (viii) James Woolsey, "This is World War IV," Herald
Sun (Melbourne), April 8, 2003, p. 19.
Interpreting Your Score
15-18 Correct: Excellent. You're probably on file
with the government's Total Information Awareness system (renamed the
Terrorism Information Awareness system to reassure the American public
[NYT, May 21, 2003, p. A20]).
10-14 Correct: Fair. You may have watched the
non-stop cable coverage of "Operation Iraqi Freedom," but
you could use a good dose of the alternative media.
5-9 Correct: Poor. But don't despair. As George W.
Bush said on Nov. 6, 2000, "They misunderestimated me."
0-4 Correct: Failing. But it doesn't matter. You
too are probably on file with the government's Total Information
Awareness system.
Source: http://psychoanalystsopposewar.org
Join our Daily News Headlines
Email Digest
|
|
Information
Clearing House
Daily News Headlines
Digest
|
HOME
COPYRIGHT NOTICE
|