The Tale of Two Countries
By Christopher Brauchli
All of
our people all over the country-except the pure blooded
Indians-are immigrants or descendants of immigrants,
including even those who came over on the Mayflower.
Franklin Delano Roosevelt,
1944 Campaign Speech
December 05, 2015 "Information
Clearing House" -
Compassion-some have it, some don't.
In a Canadian government website entitled "The
refugee system in Canada," the opening sentence states: "Our
compassion and fairness are a source of great pride for Canadians .
. . .A refugee is different from an immigrant, in that an immigrant
is a person who chooses to settle permanently in another country.
Refugees are forced to flee."
It was great news for Syrian refugees camping out
in Jordan that Canada showed how those words translated into
practice for those hoping to emigrate to Canada. On November 29,
2015, Canada
opened a refugee-processing center in Amman, Jordan. The
Center's goal is to process 500 Syrian refugees a day so that they
can leave the refugee camp. It is to become the main processing
center in the region. On November 29th there were three federal
Canadian cabinet ministers on hand to see how the newly opened
center was working. They were representatives of the government that
intends to facilitate the resettlement of large numbers of the
estimated 4 million Syrians who have been declared refugees from
that country's war. Hundreds of Canadian civil servants and soldiers
are handling the cases of those seeking to emigrate. The Canadian
government plans to resettle 25,000 Syrian refugees in Canada by the
end of February 2016 of which 10,000 will be resettled by the end of
this year. The remaining 15,000 should be resettled by the end of
February 2016. Since the beginning of November, 153 Syrian refugees
have arrived in Canada and another 928 have received visas that
enable them to travel there.
In a Canadian website entitled
#Welcome Refugees the Canadian government says that: "resettling
refugees is a proud and important part of Canada's humanitarian
tradition. It reflects our commitment to Canadians and demonstrates
to the world that we have a shared responsibility to help people who
are displaced and persecuted."
Across the border things are a bit different. No
one in the United States is talking about resettling 25,000 refugees
in the next three months. President Obama speaks hopefully of
settling 10,000 by the end of 2016. That is less than one-half of
what Canada proposes to do in considerably less time. And it seems
increasingly unlikely that the president will come anywhere close to
his goal. Compassion is no longer a word in the American vocabulary.
Thirty-one governors have said that Syrian
refugees are not welcome in their states. They have used different
language to express their opposition to admitting them. Alabama
governor, Robert Bentley, for example, said: "After full
consideration of this weekend's attacks of terror on innocent
citizens in Paris, I will oppose any attempt to relocate Syrian
refugees to Alabama through the U.S. Refugee Admissions Program. As
your governor, I will not stand complicit to a policy that places
the citizens of Alabama in harm's way." Shortly after he was sworn
in as governor in 2013, Governor Bentley signed a
bill expanding the rights of citizens of his state to carry
weapons. On December 1, 2015, two shooting deaths occurred in
Birmingham, Alabama that brought the total number of shooting deaths
in that city to 81 for the year, the first time since 2008 that
Birmingham could claim more than 80 shooting deaths in one year.
The governors opposing the admission of refugees
are inspired in their opposition by the Paris attack of two weeks
ago that killed 130 people. They have forgotten what life is like in
the United States without the terrorists even being admitted. As of
December 1 there have been 12,127 gun deaths in the United States,
24,450 gun related injuries, 640 children killed and 308 mass
shootings. All occurred without the assistance of one Syrian
refugee. None of the 12,127 gun related deaths was the result of
terrorist attacks. The mass shooting that took place on December 2
that left 13 people dead and 17 wounded was by local murderers
rather than Syrian refugees.
It is not only the elected governors who fear the
effects of a Syrian refugee inflow into the United States. The
would-be presidents in the Republican Party have equally strong
feelings. Donald Trump says if elected he would deport any Syrians
who had been admitted prior to his taking office. Ted Cruz says
bringing Syrians into the U.S. is "absolute lunacy." Chris Christie
says not even orphans under the age of five should be admitted. Rand
Paul plans to suspend visas for all people coming from countries
with "significant jihadist movements." (Whether France would be
considered such a country given recent events there is probably an
open question.)
The paragraph headings in the Canadian
government's description of the Canadian Refugee system read as
follows: Tradition of Humanitarian Action; Canadian Refugee
Protection Programs; Refugee and Humanitarian Resettlement Program;
In-Canada Asylum Program; Integration services; Assistance for
resettled refugees; Assistance for all newcomers, including
refugees.
Compassion is a 10-letter word. It has no place in
the vocabularies of more than one-half of the United States
governors and all the presidential wanna-bes among the Republicans.
This country was founded by immigrants. Go figure.
Christopher Brauchli can be emailed at
brauchli.56@post.harvard.edu. For political commentary see his web
page at
http://humanraceandothersports.com