By Finian Cunningham
July 07, 2021 "Information
Clearing House" -The Pentagon has
been castigated for undercounting the deaths
of civilians in its foreign military
operations. That might seem like ethical
criticism. But it’s woefully not enough.
Ending illegal US wars should be the real
focus.
Two US lawmakers have this week
complained to Secretary of Defense Lloyd
Austin over a Pentagon report which purports
to account for civilians killed accidentally
by American forces.
Representative Ro Hanna and Senator
Elizabeth Warren, both Democrats,
rebuked the Department of Defense (DoD)
for minimizing the number of casualties. The
lawmakers cite open sources that indicate
the Pentagon underestimated deaths by a
factor of five.
Calling for a further investigation into
the Pentagon’s admissions, the lawmakers
stated: “We need to openly consider all the
costs, benefits, and consequences of
military action, and that includes doing
everything we can to prevent and respond to
civilian harm.”
The Pentagon
report in question is an annual
accounting of civilian deaths caused by US
forces in foreign operations. It claims that
there were only 23 civilians killed during
the year 2020 in military deployments across
six countries: Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria,
Yemen, Somalia and Nigeria.
No Advertising - No Government Grants - This Is
Independent Media
It is by no means the first time that the
Pentagon has been accused of underestimating
its “collateral damage”. In a previous
report for 2019, it claimed responsibility
for 132 civilian deaths in Afghanistan, Iraq
and Syria whereas open-source figures put
the death toll for the period at nearly 10
times higher.
On reading the latest US military report,
it sounds like the epitome of legal probity
and humanitarian scruples.
It states (page 5): “All DoD operations
in 2020 were conducted in accordance
with law of war requirements, including
law of war protections for civilians,
such as the fundamental principles of
distinction and proportionality, and the
requirement to take feasible precautions
in planning and conducting attacks to
reduce the risk of harm to civilians and
other persons and objects protected from
being made the object of an attack.”
However, to get hung up on the narrow
issue about the exact number of unlawful
killings inflicted by the American military,
or on whether those deaths amount to war
crimes or not, is to miss a much more
important point. That is, the entire US
military presence in these foreign countries
is illegal and arguably amounts to the
supreme war crime of aggression.
The Pentagon report admits to operations
in just six countries. No doubt there are
more nations where US covert forces are
deployed. But let’s just take the six
admitted to.
The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq were the
result of US lies and fabrications about the
perpetrators of 9/11 and weapons of mass
destruction. There was no justification for
these wars which caused millions of deaths
over a span of two decades. Doing an annual
audit on civilian deaths is obscenely
misplaced.
Those entire military operations were
“permitted” by ad hoc US laws known as
Authorization for Use of Military Force (AUMF).
Under international law, the only foreign
military deployments that are legitimate are
those mandated by a right to self-defense
from imminent attack, or by the UN Security
Council, or by a request from an allied
government for assistance. Arguably, the US
launched its wars on Afghanistan and Iraq
without meeting any of these criteria.
In the cases of Syria, Yemen, Somalia and
Nigeria, the illegal presence of US forces
is even more salient. The invocation of AUMF
laws by Washington is grotesquely tenuous.
It is simply a carte blanche to invade
foreign nations and bomb at will. That is
nothing less than aggression and state
terrorism.
So, while Democratic lawmakers in the US
may sound ethical in their criticism of the
Pentagon over counting civilian casualties,
their concern about “proper accounting” and
“costs and benefits” is really a sham.
The real and only issue is to end all
criminal US wars that are being waged in
multiple countries simultaneously. American
lawmakers and the American public need to
realize that their government is guilty of
war crimes, not just guilty of glossing over
human horrors.
American leaders shouldn’t be receiving
letters of complaint. They should be
receiving warrants for prosecution over war
crimes.